AI-generated illustration; not a photograph of the reported event.
- calendar_today November 13, 2026
Alex Murdaugh’s Defense Challenges Murder Indictments
Alex Murdaugh’s attorneys are scheduled to appear in court on Friday, seeking to have the original murder indictments against him dismissed. They allege that the chief investigator on the case, State Law Enforcement Division (SLED) agent David Owen, misled the Colleton County grand jury during the proceedings that led to the indictments charging Murdaugh with the murders of his wife and son.
Convictions Thrown Out and Retrial Ordered
The challenge comes after the South Carolina Supreme Court overturned Murdaugh’s earlier convictions and life sentence. The court determined that a court clerk had improperly influenced jurors against Murdaugh during his 2023 trial. Despite this, even if Judge Debra McCaslin grants the defense motion to dismiss the indictments at Friday’s hearing, prosecutors could quickly seek new grand jury indictments, and a retrial is still scheduled for April. Murdaugh’s attorneys have stated they would not prevent new indictments from being sought.
Allegations Against Chief Investigator David Owen
This move would, however, mark another criticism of agent David Owen. In a separate case last year, Owen was involved in a murder case that was dismissed after it was revealed he failed to communicate key information about a victim’s suicide threat to prosecutors and defense attorneys. Owen retired in 2024, shortly after receiving State Law Enforcement Officer of the Year honors. He has admitted to making mistakes in the Murdaugh investigation but has denied deliberately misleading the grand jury.
The Case Against Murdaugh and Evidence Questioned
Prosecutors allege that in 2021, Alex Murdaugh, then 58, killed his wife, Maggie, and son, Paul, on their South Carolina property. Murdaugh has been convicted on unrelated financial crimes and is serving sentences for stealing millions from clients, admitting to being a thief, insurance cheat, and long-term opioid addict—claims he has acknowledged in court. However, he continues to deny involvement in the murders.
Defense attorneys argue that Owen falsely testified before the grand jury about key forensic evidence. Specifically, the defense claims Owen told jurors there was blood spatter found on Murdaugh’s T-shirt from the night of the killings, despite earlier state reports finding no blood stains and no such evidence being presented at trial. Additionally, Owen reportedly told the jury that ammunition matching what was used in the murders was found throughout the property, though this assertion was incorrect.
Prosecution’s Response and Other Evidence
Prosecutors have denied allegations of deliberate misconduct by their team, stating “a single mistake is not bad faith” and maintaining they possess significant evidence to support the murder charges. Among the evidence presented to the grand jury was a video recorded by Paul Murdaugh in which Alex Murdaugh’s voice can be heard at the scene, contradicting Murdaugh’s denials of being present. Prosecutors also presented information about the family’s escalating debts and the imminent exposure of Murdaugh’s financial misdeeds.
Legal experts suggest that, even if the case is dismissed based on alleged misconduct, prosecutors could pursue new indictments with the remaining evidence.
Murdaugh’s Legal Situation Moving Forward
Despite the overturned murder convictions, Murdaugh remains in prison on federal and state charges related to financial crimes. The outcome of renewed murder indictment challenges or potential retrial will not affect his current sentences for these financial crimes. Prosecutors have previously argued Murdaugh orchestrated the murders to elicit sympathy and delay the unraveling of his financial schemes.
Source: cbsnews.com.
